It's very possible that increasing the scope of the site will decrease the quality of information. While this is not guaranteed, I would worry about it happening. I also imagine that it would be difficult to moderate given the amount of information that would be here.
Maybe I just like having a moonkin place, but there's already offspec forums. Isn't that good enough?
No one has been really using the forums. Alot of people who have main spec's of Feral and Resto normally go to EJ or the Wow Forums.
Ej is millions of pages upon itself and..well..The Wow Forums..are the wow forums? Most people that come here, only look for Moonkin advice because the site is known as a Moonkin Site. We wanted to give the Offspec discussion its own forum so others can feel welcomed to come here and chat about stuff without the worry of the amazing trolls that plague the WoW Forums, or the hate you can get when you ask something to be clarified on EJ.
I guess I feel like if there was a real call for a feral and resto forum, we would already see them independently. Also, I wouldn't mind sister sites. But if I would have to filter through all non-moonkin stuff on the new posts page to see what's recent, I think I'd stop doing it. Also, calls for help would get more confusing.
I'd prefer to either stay the same or have sister sites with different names that maybe are accessible through permalinks at the top of the page.